Why a staff share scheme could help Pick n Pay
Source: https://fm.co.za/news-and-fox/2026-11-04-why-a-staff-share-scheme-could-help-pick-n-pay/
Source: https://fm.co.za/news-and-fox/2026-11-04-why-a-staff-share-scheme-could-help-pick-n-pay/
Labour federation says potential exclusion from the trade pact with the US should be an opportunity for SA’s government to seek other trade partners – and criticises its slow pace in this regard.

One of the biggest issues Cosatu has noted among investors is that it takes them about 14 months to get through all the bureaucracy. Image: Moneyweb
Matthew Parks, the parliamentary coordinator for the Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu), has been traveling to the US a lot lately, as part of his efforts to lobby for South Africa’s continued inclusion in the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa).
He has been meeting labour constituencies in the US, charting a way to keep South Africa in Agoa and protect the jobs and communities that depend on it.
Read: SA dangles chicken and pork concessions to the US for Agoa continuation
He warns that SA’s removal from Agoa would hit agriculture and manufacturing sectors the hardest, with estimates of around 3 000 job losses, or close to 10 000 overall.
Parks has also criticised SA’s government for not moving fast enough to support affected companies or diversify its trading partners.
In this interview with Moneyweb, Parks explains why remaining in Agoa is the ideal outcome, what should happen if SA is removed, and why he believes a potential exclusion should spur the government to seek new markets.
Q: Representatives of government, business, labour and community organisations recently met the National Economic Development and Labour Council (Nedlac) to discuss the possibility of SA’s exclusion from Agoa. What was the mood at the Nedlac meetings?
Parks: The Nedlac partners are concerned. That is partly because things are clouded by SA’s relationship with the US, which has not been in a great space for the past couple of years – in fact, not for the past four years. Even under former fresident Joe Biden there were issues, but a different set of issues.
I think government needs to pay more attention to our relationship with other countries, especially the major economies, and diversify our trade.
We should not take for granted relationships with the European Union, China and African countries. We must pay a bit more attention to them collectively.
Q: What do you see as the best outcome in terms of SA’s place in Aoga?
Parks: The US Congress extended Agoa for two years because that is what it decided.
Given the volatility, two years is a good base. Remember that last year it had expired completely. Ideally, SA remains a member of Agoa. That is the ideal option because it benefits a lot of companies and jobs, especially in the agricultural and manufacturing sectors.
If we are removed, the next thing we need to do is continue to engage with the US for it to reconsider its decision.
We were threatened with removal once before, about 10 years ago, around the pork and poultry issues – which are still issues.
That [not being removed] provided space for the government to engage when Rob Davies was minister [of trade and industry] and to find a solution.
Read: Agoa extension offers African exporters two more years
Hopefully, that is our plan B. Even if we are removed beyond that, we should keep engaging.
Other countries have been removed for different reasons. Their circumstances are very different from ours, but we should still engage because the reality is that the US is the world’s largest economy. It is our second- or third-largest trading partner, competing with Germany for that spot. It is also a major source of investment, and we want to increase trade with the US.
Q: How severe would removal be for jobs and the economy?
Parks: The statistics we have seen talk about job losses of around 3 000, or under 10 000.
About 10% of our trade is with the US, and that has been declining because of President Donald Trump’s tariffs. Out of that 10%, about 20% is through Agoa.
Most of our trade with the US is minerals, and minerals are exempt from tariffs. Manufacturing – like cars and steel – is already at a global 25% tariff when exported to the US.
So the impact would really be around agriculture and manufacturing.
The stats from various economists talk about around 3 000 jobs, but for those 3 000 – many of them in the Western Cape – it is quite devastating. It will not collapse the economy per se. But if you are a company in Atlantis, Western Cape, and you retrench workers, that is a devastating blow for that community.
Q: The SA government promised support for affected companies a year ago, if the exclusion from Agoa becomes a reality. Has the government delivered?
Parks: That is our point of frustration. A year ago, the government said it would put measures in place to support companies. A year later, that has not happened. The losses may not be as much as we initially feared if we exit, but if your contract comes to an end, [and] you retrench workers and you close the doors, that is not much comfort.
The government had indicated that Unemployment Insurance Fund [UIF] support could be an option. I can say that option is impractical because the process is a mess.
Read: UIF under fire, but no administration request yet
It takes companies about 14 months of endless red tape to get relief from the UIF.
During Covid it was slightly different because anyone affected could get it; the rules are now stricter – you must show how you are struggling, and so on. But the principle is the same: companies just do not get it.
They have allocated R2.5 billion, and barely 10% of that money has been released to assist companies.
We have been having this engagement with the US since 2018. The UIF is not going to help in time. It must be fixed, but that fix will not happen by 3 November [the first full day of political and market reaction after the US is widely expected to announce its annual Agoa eligibility decision for SA].
We have proposed alternatives. The minister talked about subsidies through the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition, and that would be good.
What we have also proposed is Covid-style tax relief – allowing companies to claim back whatever losses they had through tax relief.
At least Sars [South African Revenue Service] is very efficient and can do that immediately. The problem with some of the other measures is that they take time, and if you are a company, you do not have the luxury of time.
Q: You have met Cosatu’s sister union in the US, AFL-CIO, and steelworkers in the US about 10 times since 2022. How important is that labour support, and do you think this will help in having a positive outcome for SA?
Parks: Yes, we are in constant contact with them. I have been to the US about 10 times on this issue since 2022. They are close to us on this issue and have supported us.
In fact, I was there in June at their congress and met with the steelworkers. They are supporting us. That is why the Agoa renewal passed Congress with overwhelming bipartisan support.
The review itself is done by the administration. So it is an administration decision. Then there is the US Trade Representative, which looks at trade issues, but ultimately it goes to the US president, who would most likely look at political and bilateral relations. That becomes a bit more complicated.
Q: If South Africa is removed, can it get back in before the change takes effect?
Parks: If you are removed, that only takes effect in January. So you have 60 days. Is there space to prevent that? Hopefully.
But there are other things we still need to do. We still need to diversify our trade relations. We need to do that because of our own domestic crisis of 43% unemployment and weak economic growth.
They have done some of that, especially in agriculture, which is the most vulnerable sector. You have seen some movement towards Asia.
But it must be done in a way that does not create other issues, because the problem with China and India is the strings attached.
They want you to open up your market as well, and we are not really in a space to compete equally with them.
Q: How much negotiating power does South Africa have with the US?
Parks: Not much. It is a different style – largely a take-it-or-leave-it approach. And of course it is clouded by bilateral issues that are not related to trade. The US must negotiate from a tough basis because it is looking after its own constituencies, just as SA must do likewise.
Q: Are we giving in too much to the US with concessions?
Parks: I do not think so. The goal of negotiation is about giving something, but it has not even reached that stage yet. This is an unusual time, so the old textbooks do not really apply in the same way.
Q: Should South Africa sacrifice constitutional imperatives, especially on transformation and land rights to appease the US?
Parks: We cannot outsource sovereign choices to another country. That would be political suicide.
That does not mean we do not tweak legislation, policies or regulations, but it must be guided by our domestic economic constraints. If growth is sluggish and unemployment is too high – which they are – then we should look at whether we need to make amendments to our own policies and legislation. That must be guided by South African conditions.
For example, on the B-BBEE review that the government is already busy with, we have said: why not extend equity equivalents for investors who cannot do the 30% shareholding because of their own domestic legislation?
Why not extend employee share-ownership programmes, which many countries prefer, as opposed to the 30% option?
Read: High court sets aside Tau’s decision to gazette legal sector BEE code
You can find ways to complement the transformation journey while also making it easier for investors to come in. That includes reducing red tape.
One of the biggest things we have seen from investors is not so much on the issue of compliance, but that it takes them about 14 months to get through all the bureaucracy.
We should really be discussing how to reduce that to 14 days, for example, not 14 months.
But that must not mean tinkering with labour standards and labour rights. Luckily, that has not really come up in this round of discussion. We cannot compromise on labour rights, but that does not mean we do not make changes. Changes must be guided by our real economic challenges.

Trade, Industry and Competition Minister Parks Tau / Gallo Images
The National Economic Development and Labour Council (Nedlac) has considered measures to cushion South African businesses and workers from the impact of losing preferential access to the US market, as labour federation Cosatu warns that the country would probably be excluded from the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa).
The contingency measures were discussed at a formal meeting between Trade, Industry and Competition Minister Parks Tau and Nedlac members on October 29, as the government awaited the outcome of the US review of South Africa’s eligibility for Agoa benefits in 2027. The US is expected to announce its decision on Monday, November 2.
Cosatu parliamentary coordinator Matthew Parks said the discussions examined different scenarios facing South Africa and the interventions that could be considered if the US decided to remove the country from the programme.
Nedlac and Trade Minister Parks Tau discussed contingency measures to help South African businesses and workers potentially losing preferential access to the US market under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa), with the US decision expected on November 2.
Labour federation Cosatu warned South Africa would probably be excluded from Agoa, emphasizing targeted assistance like tax relief for companies and workers most affected, particularly in the Western Cape and Northern Cape agriculture sectors.
South Africa faces regional risks due to interconnected supply chains, especially in the automotive sector, involving countries such as Lesotho and Botswana, and the government is pursuing diplomatic efforts to retain Agoa access.
Cosatu criticized the lack of trade attachés in South African embassies worldwide, advocating for closer embassy cooperation with trade and agriculture departments to boost export promotion and market access.
Discussions included diversifying trade relations with Asian markets like Vietnam, South Korea, and China, and reviewing domestic policies like black economic empowerment without compromising transformation goals.

Cosatu general secretary Zingiswa Losi urges workers to support the ANC and SACP in the 2026 local government elections, while calling for urgent action on municipal debt, corruption, skills shortages and failing services.Picture: File picture
The Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu) and workers across South Africa keenly await our local government elections, our most contested since 1994.
It is no exaggeration to state that much is at stake in these, from municipal workers correctly expecting to be paid on time to working-class communities needing basic services to businesses requiring modern infrastructure.
Society is legitimately frustrated by the state of many municipalities, but we should equally not forget the massive strides we have made since 1994 under successive African National Congress (ANC) led administrations to transform society for the better.
Before 1994, a third of South African households had electricity and half had access to water and sanitation. Today it is more than 90%.
Similar outstanding success stories can be seen with the expanding network of paved roads, clinics and other essential social and economic infrastructure.
These have played an important role in dismantling apartheid’s legacies, opening access to the economy for all and tackling poverty and inequality. These are no small achievements.
Whilst we applaud these massive gains, we must be equally concerned and pained by the cancers of state capture and corruption in many municipalities that have become a national shame.
The number of municipalities experiencing financial distress has jumped from 10% to over 60% in the past decade.
Up to three dozen municipalities struggle to pay staff salaries.
Many have severely neglected their infrastructure causing some companies to close and retrench workers.
These were once challenges afflicting rural communities, today they have become a crisis for our cities.
The Medium-Term Budget Policy Statement tabled at Parliament provides several important interventions, in particular R28 billion to rebuild metropolitan municipalities’ billing capacities, R60 billion water infrastructure investments and R21 billion to ensure indigent households receive their free basic services.
Whilst these are welcome interventions, they are not enough to stablise and rebuild increasingly embattled municipalities.
Key to fixing local government is tackling the municipal debt crisis with monies owed by residents, businesses and even the state to municipalities exceeding R485 billion and subsequently their owing Eskom over R120 billion and similarly alarming debts to water boards.
Given our dire national crises of weak 1% economic growth and 43.8% unemployment, we do not have the luxury of time.
Our new Councillors must hit the ground running and deal with the key burning challenges.
The Municipal Finance Management Act requires municipalities to pay service providers within 30 days.
This must be honoured at all times.
The Basic Conditions of Employment Act compels all employers to pay their staff in full and on time without fail, including their pensions, medical aids and taxes.
The days of this not happening must now end without exception.
The ANC and the South African Communist Party’s elections manifestos speak to insourcing municipal functions and integrating Expanded Public and Community Works’ Programmes’ workers into their respective municipalities.
These are key to removing the pandemic of state capture and corruption from local government, to saving scarce funds otherwise diverted to tenderpreneurs’ need for profit, and to promoting decent work not cheap labour.
It is precisely for these and other progressive commitments that will advance working class struggles that Cosatu urges its members and all workers to vote for the ANC and SACP on the 4th.
Political parties must deploy their best and not their weakest to run local government and when their deployees fail, they must be removed swiftly. Councils must invest in and require Councillors to undergo continuous training, including acquiring matric certificates and tertiary qualifications.
Municipal managers must be appointed based upon their skills, qualifications and experience.
We cannot have senior management in charge of complex matters ranging from finance to engineering services lacking the relevant skills and qualifications.
The Department of Cooperative Governance (DCOG) must ensure this happens without exception.
The Special Investigations Unit and the National Prosecuting Authority with the assistance of the Police and the Auditor-General must be tasked to weed out corrupt and criminal elements from local government. This has to include lifestyle audits of Councillors and management by the SIU and the South African Revenue Service.
Treasury and DCOG must expedite the retabling of the Public Procurement Act plus overhaul and put in place transparent, online municipal procurement systems to end the wild west that is local government procurement.
Interventions by Treasury to rebuild municipal billing capacity must be extended to all municipalities, in particular the most indebted and dysfunctional. Legislation must be amended to ringfence water, sanitation and electricity revenue for those core functions’ infrastructure maintenance.
This will require a new municipal funding model be put in place to ensure municipalities, in particular those lacking a self-sufficient rates base, are provided with adequate financing to fulfill their constitutional obligations.
A discussion needs to take place on the sustainable number of municipalities and which of the 257 should be integrated.
Eskom, SANRAL, the Department of Water and Sanitation and water boards must be enlisted to help rebuild municipal capacity to deliver and maintain electricity, water, sanitation and roads. Where municipalities cannot manage such capacity in the long-term, then these institutions should permanently take over these functions.
Constitutional and legislative amendments are needed to enable national government to act swiftly and timeously when municipalities fall foul of the law or experience severe challenges.
This needs to be accompanied by early warning systems to enable such interventions to be proactive and not merely reactive, by which stage the rot is often too deep.
Parliament, in particular the National Council of Provinces, and the Provincial Legislatures need to drastically ramp up their respective scrutiny of local government and hold delinquent municipalities accountable.
Whilst the challenges facing local government are daunting, they must be fixed.
This is key to saving and creating decent jobs, to unlocking economic opportunities and growth, and to delivering a better life for all, in particular the poor and the working class.
South Africa has shown that it can overcome often insurmountable odds, we must do it once again.
COSATU says ultra-cheap imports from Shein and Temu are undermining South African manufacturers and retailers, after adopting a resolution calling for the platforms to be banned.