Numsa general secretary Irvin Jim. Picture Veli Nhlapo

 

 

The labour registrar, Lehlohonolo Molefe, has written to Numsa general secretary Irvin Jim demanding outstanding consolidated annual audited financial statements for the years ended December 2021, 2022, 2023 and 2024.

The statements should account for all the union’s assets, including investments, and its liabilities worth hundreds of millions of rand, Molefe said.

The regional leaders of the National Union of Metalworkers of SA (Numsa) have approached the high court in Johannesburg seeking to interdict the national leadership from acting as signatories to the union’s bank accounts and investments. This comes as the battle for control of one of South Africa’s largest and wealthiest unions intensifies. The matter is scheduled to be heard on Tuesday.

According to the letter, dated November 12 and which Business Day has seen, Numsa received qualified audit opinions during 2021 to 2024 for several reasons, including the nonconsolidation of financial statements.

Molefe wrote that the audit opinions for the years ended December 2021, 2022, 2023 and 2024 failed to satisfy the requirements of the Labour Relations Act (LRA).

The labour registrar also wants details of the regional congresses that have taken place before the national congress to elect a new leadership scheduled for later in November.

Molefe warned in the letter that failure to provide the requested information will invoke provisions of the LRA. The labour registrar is known to place under administration unions that fail to comply with their constitution and the country’s labour legislation.

“The Chemical, Energy, Paper, Printing, Wood and Allied Workers’ Union (Ceppwawu), a Cosatu affiliate, was placed under administration by the labour registrar in June 2020 after failing to manage its affairs effectively since 2018,” he said.

Molefe said his office was aware that Numsa had held its most recent national congress in 2022 and wanted Jim to confirm whether another congress had since been held. If so, he was asked to provide evidence that the meeting had been properly convened and held.

The labour registrar called on Jim to submit copies of minutes and signed attendance registers of central committee meetings, national executive committee meetings, and national finance committee meetings held from January 2022, and provide proof of compliance with the constitution in the way such meetings are held.

“You are kindly requested to submit the requested information not later than 30 days from the date of this letter. Please note that if there is a failure to submit the requested information, this office will invoke the relevant provisions of the LRA,” Molefe said.

Numsa national spokesperson Mbali Ngwenda said the union shall “duly reply to the registrar, and as such, it will be inappropriate to deal with the content of such response at this stage through the press”.

“Suffice to record that the content of the letter indeed came as a surprise in that nothing contained in the previous exchanges between Numsa and the registrar foreshadowed what is now contained in the registrar’s correspondence.

“While the registrar had made some inquiries in the past, to which Numsa had duly replied, Numsa was at all material times under the impression that these issues were addressed to the registrar’s satisfaction.

“While Numsa is not making any allegations whatsoever against the registrar at this stage, it is a matter of grave concern that Mr Nkosinathi Makhanya, one of the rogue elements who have recently unsuccessfully attempted to stage a coup of Numsa with irregular funding provided from the Numsa Investment Company by Mr Khandani Msibi (the disgraced former NIC CEO) and who was himself dismissed from the Numsa Investment Company, was on record during a recent interview on eNCA to the effect that he had a meeting with the registrar, and at that meeting it was alleged that it transpired that Numsa was allegedly not compliant in respect of its financial reporting.

“It is also very surprising that the very same Makhanya was in the meetings that endorsed the Numsa financial statements that were submitted to the registrar of labour.

“If the aforesaid is true, it is of immense concern to Numsa that the registrar is giving an audience to persons who are not representing Numsa and who clearly have no interest in Numsa’s wellbeing and who are in fact advancing the interests of persons who are intent on orchestrating Numsa’s demise.

“Numsa will raise this with the registrar in conjunction with responding to each of the registrar’s questions.”

Molefe’s letter came as Numsa regional leaders approached the labour court and banks on an urgent basis to remove “suspended” general secretary Jim and other national office bearers as signatories to the union’s bank accounts and interdict them from performing their official duties as they are suspended.

The move followed the recent suspension of the national leadership after it was stripped of its delegated powers and functions over infighting for control of the metalworkers’ union.

Numsa’s national office bearers, including Jim, announced recently that their special national executive committee had resolved to suspend the regional leaders, who had earlier said they had lost confidence in the office bearers.

However, the regional leaders announced at a media briefing that their own executive committee, which met a week ago, had resolved to suspend the office bearers on charges of dereliction of duty, conduct bringing the union into disrepute, gross violations of the Numsa constitution and constitutional procedures, and wasteful expenditure.

The central committee meeting held by the regional leaders in October resolved to strip the national office bearers, including Jim and president Andrew Chirwa, of their powers and replace them with a task co-ordinating team.

The regional leaders’ special national executive committee meeting had maintained that the central committee meeting of October 23 was “properly constituted” and that its decisions remain valid and binding.

“No court of law has set aside those decisions.”

Numsa Mpumalanga regional chair Nkosinathi Makhanya told Business Day the union’s central committee, its highest decision-making structure between the union’s congresses, had appointed acting national office bearers last Thursday. They include Andile Nqilingwane (acting president), Xola Balfour (acting national treasurer), Silumko Nondwangu (acting general secretary) and Karl Cloete (acting deputy general secretary).

Makhanya said Numsa had also approached the labour court and the Johannesburg high court for an order removing the national office bearers as signatories to the union’s FNB and Absa bank accounts and at Old Mutual Investment Services.

“We are waiting for a court judgment … that will confirm whether the October 23rd central committee was constitutional or not after Jim cancelled it at night and regions proceeded [to hold it],” Makhanya said.

If the labour court confirms the legality of the central meeting of October 23, “then that would mean all the decisions taken at that meeting, including the stripping of the national office bearers of their powers, are legal and stand. It would effectively nullify their status as national office bearers”.

Jim announced last week that the regional leaders’ Numsa membership had been terminated.

The power struggle and counter-suspensions were viewed as threatening the credibility of the union, the backbone of the South African Federation of Trade Unions (Saftu).

At its peak before its expulsion from Cosatu in November 2014, Numsa was its largest affiliate with about 360,000 members.

Regional leaders from the Eastern Cape, KwaZulu-Natal, JC Bez, Mpumalanga and Sedibeng defied Jim by convening the central committee meeting in October. Jim had written to them to say the meeting scheduled for October 23-25 had been cancelled until further notice.

The letter by Jim came after a ruling by labour court judge Edwin Tlhotlhalemaje preventing Numsa and the office bearers from barring delegates from Mpumalanga from attending, participating and voting at committee meetings.

The dispute between Numsa’s regional and national leaders arose from events at the Mpumalanga regional congress on June 29 and 30. Before the congress, the region’s Ehlanzeni local shop stewards council resolved that local office bearers would identify and nominate delegates from among its members.

After the congress, a shop steward complained directly to Jim that the process used to select delegates from Ehlanzeni structures was unlawful. They alleged that the election of Ehlanzeni council delegates contravened the Numsa constitution, “which in turn called into question the status of the regional congress and the delegates elected at that congress”.

In a letter to all central committee delegates dated September 4, Chirwa announced that the committee would reconvene without the Mpumalanga delegates, prompting Makhanya to approach the courts for relief.

In his ruling, Tlhotlhalemaje interdicted the office bearers from excluding the Mpumalanga delegation and found that Chirwa “on his own or with the general secretary” had “usurped the powers of the central committee, acted ultra vires, and put the cart before the horse”, which “amounts to self-help”.


Source: https://www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2026-11-17-labour-registrar-demands-numsas-audited-financial-statements/