Numsa’s task co-ordinating team led by the union’s Sedibeng regional chairperson Junior Gusha briefs the media at the Birchwood Hotel in Boksburg, on November 3 2026. Picture: Freddy Mavunda/Business Day
Story audio is generated using AI
The leadership of the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (Numsa), one of South Africa’s largest unions, is in limbo after regional and national leaders suspended each other in a power struggle over control of the metalworkers’ union.
In scenes reminiscent of the 2021 power struggle between then ANC secretary-general Ace Magashule and party leader Cyril Ramaphosa, when Magashule attempted to suspend Ramaphosa before being suspended himself, Numsa’s national office bearers and regional leaders have suspended each other in less than a week.
The power struggle and counter-suspensions are threatening the credibility of the union, the backbone of the South African Federation of Trade Unions (Saftu).
At its peak before its expulsion from Cosatu in November 2014, Numsa was its largest affiliate with about 360,000 members.
The national office bearers announced last Thursday that their special national executive committee (NEC) had resolved to suspend the regional leaders, who in turn said they had lost confidence in them.
However, the regional leaders announced at a media briefing on Tuesday that their own executive committee, which met on Monday, had resolved to suspend the office bearers on charges of dereliction of duty, conduct bringing the union into disrepute, gross violations of the Numsa constitution and constitutional procedures, and wasteful expenditure.
The regional leaders’ special national executive committee meeting maintained that the central committee meeting of October 23 was “properly constituted and that its decisions remain valid and binding. No court of law has set aside those decisions”.
The central committee meeting resolved to strip the national office bearers, including general secretary Irvin Jim and president Andrew Chirwa, of their powers and replaced them with a task co-ordinating team.
“The special national executive committee expressed serious concern about the conduct of the national office bearers, particularly the failure to respect and implement decisions of the central committee and the resulting disruption to the effective functioning of the union,” the Numsa statement announcing the outcomes of the committee meeting says.
“The executive committee believes that the continued disregard for constitutional decisions, the undermining of elected regional leadership and the emergence of competing centres of authority have contributed significantly to the organisational instability experienced by Numsa.
“After considering these matters, it resolved that the general secretary, comrade Irvin Jim, comrade Mbuso Ngubane and the remaining national office bearers be suspended forthwith from their respective duties, pending investigations into allegations of misconduct, in terms of Chapter 3(c)(v) of the Numsa constitution.”
It said the purpose of these measures was to safeguard the integrity of the union, protect its constitutional structures and ensure accountability for conduct that may have undermined organisational stability and democratic worker control.
“The committee further resolved that suspensions imposed by the national office bearers without proper constitutional authority must be lifted.”
Business Day has reported that the Numsa regional leaders had consented that the powers to suspend or implement disciplinary actions against them rested with the regional executive committee.
This after Jim and Chirwa wrote to the regional leaders on Monday, the day the regional leaders held their special national executive committee, saying the national office bearers remained the legitimate leadership, and called on them to withdraw the notice and cancel the “purported meeting, including any adjournment or reconvening of it; if proceedings have commenced, cease conducting them as a meeting of Numsa’s NEC and refrain from adopting or implementing purported decisions in that capacity”.
The national office bearers held their own special NEC last week where they resolved to suspend the regional leaders who held a central committee meeting and suspended the national office bearers, replacing them with a task co-ordinating team.
Regional leaders from the Eastern Cape, KwaZulu-Natal, JC Bez, Mpumalanga and Sedibeng defied Jim by convening a central committee meeting recently, the highest decision-making body between national congresses. Jim had written to them to say the meeting scheduled for October 23-25 had been cancelled until further notice.
The letter by Jim followed a ruling by labour court judge Edwin Tlhotlhalemaje preventing Numsa and the office-bearers from barring delegates from Mpumalanga from attending, participating and voting at committee meetings.
At the central committee meeting (October 23-25), the regional leaders, including Andile Bloko, Nkosinathi Makhanya and Andile Nqilingwane, resolved to strip the national office of their delegated powers and functions.
“The special national executive recognises that Numsa is confronting a serious organisational challenge that requires decisive, collective and constitutionally grounded intervention. The union’s recovery cannot be achieved through factional manoeuvring, intimidation, the manipulation of constitutional provisions or the undermining of democratically elected structures. It requires honesty, accountability, organisational discipline and respect for the collective decisions of the membership.”
Numsa national spokesperson Mbali Ngwenda has been approached for comment, which will be added once received.
The Agoa dispute has added an international dimension to the parties’ competing election messages. Graphic: Dorothy Kgosi
The US’s decision to withdraw South Africa’s Agoa benefits has exposed divisions between the ANC and DA over the country’s foreign policy, with the governing party alleging an attempt to influence voters as the ANC faces mounting electoral pressure.
The ANC, on the one hand, has questioned the timing of Washington’s decision to withdraw South Africa’s preferential trade benefits from January 2027, suggesting it could be an attempt to intimidate voters and pressure the government to abandon its transformation agenda.
The DA, on the other hand, has blamed the exclusion on the ANC’s foreign policy and what it describes as the diplomatic failures of international relations minister Ronald Lamola.
Both parties are key members of the government of national unity currently running the country. They also run some metro councils together in coalition with some smaller parties.
The competing positions come as the Ipsos Khayabus “Pulse of the people” survey shows the ANC at its lowest level of support, with the DA gaining ground as the political landscape becomes increasingly fragmented. The uMkhonto we Sizwe party registered 12%, and the EFF 10%, leaving no party with a national majority.
The Agoa dispute has added an international dimension to the parties’ competing election messages, exposing divisions over how South Africa should balance its domestic transformation policies with its economic and diplomatic relationship with Washington.
In a statement on Tuesday, the ANC rejected what it described as the weaponisation of Agoa against South Africa’s economic transformation agenda, saying the timing of the announcement alongside special voting raised concerns about attempts to influence the country’s democratic choices.
“The announcement’s timing during special voting, alongside economic misinformation, deepens concern about attempts to intimidate voters and undermine democratic choices,” the party said.
The ANC accused AfriForum, Solidarity and the DA of contributing to international pressure against South Africa through their opposition to transformation policies including broad-based BEE, land reform and employment equity.
Trade labour federation Cosatu has estimated that South Africa’s exclusion from the preferential trade programme would hit agriculture and manufacturing sectors the hardest, with estimates of about 3,000 job losses, or almost 10,000 overall.
“We’re particularly concerned about jobs in the agricultural sector, especially in the Western Cape, Limpopo and Northern Cape, where a lot of citrus farmers and other farmers export to the US,” says spokesperson Matthew Parks.
“We’re also concerned about job losses, and we’ve seen some already over the past year and a half because of the fluctuation of tariffs from the US.
“But I think it’s important not to create too much alarm, because it doesn’t mean you can’t export to the US; you can continue to export to the US.
“This just means that you lose about three-and-a-half percent of the reduced tariff regime towards the US. So you’re three and a half more expensive, in other words, for customers in the US.”
The DA, however, described South Africa’s exclusion as avoidable, blaming Lamola’s handling of relations with Washington and what it called the ANC’s ideological approach to foreign policy.
The party argued that the government’s relationships with Russia and Iran, with its domestic transformation policies, had contributed to South Africa being viewed with suspicion by liberal democracies.
It also accused the ANC of undermining economic growth through BEE legislation and said its refusal to engage with the DA on domestic policy reform in the government of national unity had contributed to the breakdown in relations.
The DA’s criticism of the ANC’s transformation policies and foreign policy positions overlaps with arguments advanced by AfriForum and Solidarity in their engagements with the Trump administration.
Both organisations have lobbied US officials over land reform, affirmative action and employment equity, arguing that these policies discriminate against minorities. Their campaigns have also promoted claims of persecution of white Afrikaners and targeted attacks on farmers and included calls for sanctions against South African political leaders and government officials.
The South African government has rejected allegations of a white genocide, while available evidence does not substantiate claims of a systematic campaign to eliminate white South Africans. AfriForum and Solidarity have continued to press their case in Washington, arguing that the government’s policies and foreign relations warrant intervention.
North-West University Business School economist Raymond Parsons said the withdrawal would have a limited effect on the economy as a whole, though the motor and agricultural industries would bear the brunt, putting thousands of jobs at risk.
PSG Financial Services chief economist Johann Els similarly cautioned against overstating the direct impact. About 7% of South Africa’s goods exports went to the US in 2025, worth about $16.5bn. Of these, about $1.6bn entered under Agoa preferences, representing about 0.7% of total goods exports.
Els said the bigger concern was the potential damage to business confidence, investment and diplomatic relations between the two countries.
“Less than 1% of our total goods exports currently enter the US under Agoa. This is not insignificant for the businesses and workers affected, but the bigger concern is the signal it sends to investors and the potential impact on confidence, investment and our broader relationship with the US.
“We should not confuse South Africa’s large share of total Agoa trade with the much smaller share of our own exports that depends on Agoa,” Els said.
The American Chamber of Commerce in South Africa (AmCham SA) said it noted the announcement by the US Trade Representative’s office with disappointment. It said the removal applies only to South Africa and Rwanda, and that Agoa itself remains in force, having been reauthorised to end-2028.
AmCham stressed that losing Agoa removes a tariff preference but does not stop trade. Citing analysis by XA Global Trade Advisors, it put South Africa’s net preference at about 3.5%, with annual duty savings of less than R2bn concentrated in a few companies.
The motor industry carries the largest employment risk, it said, while citrus, wine, table grapes and nuts are the most affected agricultural lines.
While the initial two-pot withdrawal applications first exposed roughly 3,000 to 5,000 defaulting employers, the latest data from the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) show the problem has deteriorated significantly.
The FSCA reported earlier this year that pension contribution arrears have climbed to R8.33 billion, affecting approximately 590,000 retirement fund members.
In some of the most severe cases, workers have had pension contributions deducted from their salaries for over 20 years without the money ever reaching their retirement funds.
The FSCA’s latest list of non-compliant employers names 6,064 companies reported for failing to meet their obligations under section 13A of the Pension Funds Act.
This legislation requires employers to pay pension contributions to the relevant retirement funds within prescribed timeframes.
The latest publication forms part of the regulator’s ongoing effort to name and shame employers that fail to comply with the law. It is the fifth such communication since the initiative began in June 2022.
The FSCA said the disclosures are intended to promote transparency and alert affected retirement fund members and other stakeholders to potential problems.
“This is critical in supporting the FSCA’s ongoing efforts to protect retirement fund members and promote regulatory compliance across the sector,” it said.
The number of reported employers has increased substantially over the past three years.
The regulator identified 5,430 employers in April 2023, compared with 16,556 employers across 75 funds as at 28 February 2026.
The latest reported arrears of R8.33 billion represent an increase of R1.04 billion, or 14.2%, from the R7.29 billion recorded in March 2025.
One of the most concerning aspects is how long some of these debts have remained unpaid. Late payment interest now accounts for 43.5% of total arrears, amounting to more than R3.6 billion.
The FSCA reported that interest had increased by 21.5%, compared with a 9% increase in the capital portion of outstanding contributions.
This means that employers are allowing pension debts to accumulate over extended periods rather than resolving them.
Arrears stretch back 15 to 20 years
The introduction of the two-pot retirement system in September 2024 helped expose the extent of the problem.
Previously, many employees only discovered that their pension contributions had not been paid over when they resigned, retired or were retrenched.
The new system allowed workers to access a portion of their retirement savings while remaining employed, bringing previously hidden contribution defaults to light.
Financial disclosures and regulatory records have highlighted cases involving financially distressed municipalities where pension contributions were deducted from employees’ salaries but not transferred to retirement funds.
Some municipal arrears reportedly stretch back 15 to 20 years, with cash-strapped councils prioritising operational expenses, electricity and water accounts, and supplier payments over their pension obligations.
Bargaining council funds covering industries such as security, manufacturing, transport, cleaning, retail and textiles represent another significant source of unpaid contributions.
These industries account for 76.9% of the reported arrears, while local government accounts for approximately 21.5%.
In some cases, employers registered workers with retirement funds but subsequently stopped making payments or paid contributions inconsistently, despite continuing to deduct employees’ portions from their salaries.
Trade unions, including the Public Servants Association (PSA) and COSATU, have condemned defaulting employers and local councils.
“Deducting hard-earned funds from employees’ paychecks without transferring them to benefit funds is not merely administrative delay—it is outright wage theft and fraud that ruins lives when workers need their safety net most,” the PSA said.
Citrus farmers and workers in export-dependent communities face uncertainty after the US announced plans to end South Africa’s AGOA trade benefits from January 2027. Image: Doctor Ngcobo / ANA Studio
Thousands of South African jobs could be at risk if the United States withdraws the country’s preferential trade benefits under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), with Cosatu estimating that 3 000 jobs could be lost, a figure that could rise to 10 000 in a worst-case scenario.
Asked how many jobs it expected to be lost following South Africa’s exclusion, Cosatu parliamentary co-ordinator Matthew Parks said: “Most likely 3 000 jobs. At most 10 000.”
Citrus Growers’ Association of Southern Africa chief executive Dr Boitshoko Ntshabele said that at least 35 000 farm-level jobs in the Western and Northern Cape were sustained by citrus exports to the US, although it was too early to estimate how many could be lost if South Africa was excluded from AGOA.
The US buys 5% to 6% of South Africa’s citrus export volume, but that trade is concentrated in those provinces.
Washington announced on Monday that it intended to end South Africa’s and Rwanda’s AGOA eligibility from January 1, 2027. The programme removes ordinary US import duties on qualifying goods from eligible African countries, although additional tariffs may still apply.
US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer cited concerns about barriers to American trade and investment, corruption, and US national security and foreign policy interests.
Parks identified agriculture, particularly citrus, and manufacturing as vulnerable in the Western Cape.
He said existing US tariffs introduced by President Donald Trump had already cost about 100 jewellery jobs in Cape Town, 450 furniture manufacturing jobs in Atlantis and Malmesbury, and 450 food-canning jobs in Tulbagh, with further losses in Cape Town’s packaging sector.
Those losses preceded the proposed AGOA withdrawal.
Cosatu called for continued negotiations and support for affected workers and companies, including industrial incentives, tax holidays and assistance through the Unemployment Insurance Fund’s Temporary Employment Relief Scheme.
“We cannot afford to abandon a single worker, business, industry or community,” the federation said.
Parks said negotiations should continue even if the January deadline passed, noting that countries previously removed from AGOA had later been reinstated.
The citrus association identified Citrusdal as heavily dependent on American buyers.
Its chairman, Gerrit van der Merwe, said growers could not readily redirect their fruit.
“A citrus grower cannot simply divert his crop to another market – markets have different phytosanitary requirements and consumer tastes. Entire orchards have been planted specifically for the US market.”
The association said losing Agoa would expose citrus exports to ordinary US duties generally ranging from 1.5 to 2.5 US cents per kilogram. Mandarins, lemons and grapefruit would face those alongside an existing 12.5% tariff, putting exporters at a disadvantage to competitors such as Peru and Chile.
Ntshabele said a bilateral trade agreement with the US would be the best solution. Alternatively, she proposed separate Agoa treatment for seasonal fresh produce.
Agricultural economist Wandile Sihlobo said the US accounted for about 4% of South Africa’s agricultural exports, worth $504 million in 2025. Losing preferential access would not close the American market but could make products less competitive.
He urged diversification into Asia and the Middle East without abandoning established markets.
Johann Els, chief economist at PSG Financial Services, said the direct effect on national economic growth was likely to be small.
“The bigger concern is the potential impact on business confidence, investment and diplomatic relations between the two countries,” he said.
IMM Graduate School research dean Dr Ernest van Biljon said national trade figures could conceal the impact on individual communities. Automotive products accounted for 64% of Agoa exports in 2024, although Europe bought more than half of South Africa’s automotive export volumes, he said.
Naamsa, the Automotive Business Council, was approached for comment but had not responded at the time of writing.
Government said Agoa exports fell from $4 billion in 2024 to about $1.7 billion in 2025, representing roughly 10% of South African exports to the US. Most exports entered under ordinary trade terms.
Pretoria said it had offered further trade concessions to Washington and would assess the impact on individual companies while retaining measures introduced in response to earlier US tariffs.
Pick n Pay gutted staff benefits to save R500m a year. Workers proposed getting shares in return, but battered shareholders may balk
No doubt for both sides it was an existential battle. In one corner was Pick n Pay management, utterly convinced it had to extract R500m of annualised costs and create a “sustainable labour model” that would help drag the company back onto a profit trajectory. The just-released interim results, with a trading loss after leases of an eye-watering R1.1bn, were an unnecessary reminder that extreme action was needed.
In the opposing corner, the South African Commercial Catering & Allied Workers’ Union (Saccawu) was determined not to add any Pick n Pay workers to the rapidly growing ranks of the unemployed. The workers were facing a devastating scenario, with the most recent stats showing that 345,000 people were added to the army of the jobless in the second quarter, taking the total to 8.5-million.
Labour federation says potential exclusion from the trade pact with the US should be an opportunity for SA’s government to seek other trade partners – and criticises its slow pace in this regard.
One of the biggest issues Cosatu has noted among investors is that it takes them about 14 months to get through all the bureaucracy. Image: Moneyweb
Matthew Parks, the parliamentary coordinator for the Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu), has been traveling to the US a lot lately, as part of his efforts to lobby for South Africa’s continued inclusion in the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa).
He has been meeting labour constituencies in the US, charting a way to keep South Africa in Agoa and protect the jobs and communities that depend on it.
He warns that SA’s removal from Agoa would hit agriculture and manufacturing sectors the hardest, with estimates of around 3 000 job losses, or close to 10 000 overall.
Parks has also criticised SA’s government for not moving fast enough to support affected companies or diversify its trading partners.
In this interview with Moneyweb, Parks explains why remaining in Agoa is the ideal outcome, what should happen if SA is removed, and why he believes a potential exclusion should spur the government to seek new markets.
Q: Representatives of government, business, labour and community organisations recently met the National Economic Development and Labour Council (Nedlac) to discuss the possibility of SA’s exclusion from Agoa. What was the mood at the Nedlac meetings?
Parks: The Nedlac partners are concerned. That is partly because things are clouded by SA’s relationship with the US, which has not been in a great space for the past couple of years – in fact, not for the past four years. Even under former fresident Joe Biden there were issues, but a different set of issues.
I think government needs to pay more attention to our relationship with other countries, especially the major economies, and diversify our trade.
We should not take for granted relationships with the European Union, China and African countries. We must pay a bit more attention to them collectively.
Q: What do you see as the best outcome in terms of SA’s place in Aoga?
Parks: The US Congress extended Agoa for two years because that is what it decided.
Given the volatility, two years is a good base. Remember that last year it had expired completely. Ideally, SA remains a member of Agoa. That is the ideal option because it benefits a lot of companies and jobs, especially in the agricultural and manufacturing sectors.
If we are removed, the next thing we need to do is continue to engage with the US for it to reconsider its decision.
We were threatened with removal once before, about 10 years ago, around the pork and poultry issues – which are still issues.
That [not being removed] provided space for the government to engage when Rob Davies was minister [of trade and industry] and to find a solution.
Hopefully, that is our plan B. Even if we are removed beyond that, we should keep engaging.
Other countries have been removed for different reasons. Their circumstances are very different from ours, but we should still engage because the reality is that the US is the world’s largest economy. It is our second- or third-largest trading partner, competing with Germany for that spot. It is also a major source of investment, and we want to increase trade with the US.
Q: How severe would removal be for jobs and the economy?
Parks: The statistics we have seen talk about job losses of around 3 000, or under 10 000.
About 10% of our trade is with the US, and that has been declining because of President Donald Trump’s tariffs. Out of that 10%, about 20% is through Agoa.
Most of our trade with the US is minerals, and minerals are exempt from tariffs. Manufacturing – like cars and steel – is already at a global 25% tariff when exported to the US.
So the impact would really be around agriculture and manufacturing.
The stats from various economists talk about around 3 000 jobs, but for those 3 000 – many of them in the Western Cape – it is quite devastating. It will not collapse the economy per se. But if you are a company in Atlantis, Western Cape, and you retrench workers, that is a devastating blow for that community.
Q: The SA government promised support for affected companies a year ago, if the exclusion from Agoa becomes a reality. Has the government delivered?
Parks: That is our point of frustration. A year ago, the government said it would put measures in place to support companies. A year later, that has not happened. The losses may not be as much as we initially feared if we exit, but if your contract comes to an end, [and] you retrench workers and you close the doors, that is not much comfort.
The government had indicated that Unemployment Insurance Fund [UIF] support could be an option. I can say that option is impractical because the process is a mess.
It takes companies about 14 months of endless red tape to get relief from the UIF.
During Covid it was slightly different because anyone affected could get it; the rules are now stricter – you must show how you are struggling, and so on. But the principle is the same: companies just do not get it.
They have allocated R2.5 billion, and barely 10% of that money has been released to assist companies.
We have been having this engagement with the US since 2018. The UIF is not going to help in time. It must be fixed, but that fix will not happen by 3 November [the first full day of political and market reaction after the US is widely expected to announce its annual Agoa eligibility decision for SA].
We have proposed alternatives. The minister talked about subsidies through the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition, and that would be good.
What we have also proposed is Covid-style tax relief – allowing companies to claim back whatever losses they had through tax relief.
At least Sars [South African Revenue Service] is very efficient and can do that immediately. The problem with some of the other measures is that they take time, and if you are a company, you do not have the luxury of time.
Q: You have met Cosatu’s sister union in the US, AFL-CIO, and steelworkers in the US about 10 times since 2022. How important is that labour support, and do you think this will help in having a positive outcome for SA?
Parks: Yes, we are in constant contact with them. I have been to the US about 10 times on this issue since 2022. They are close to us on this issue and have supported us.
In fact, I was there in June at their congress and met with the steelworkers. They are supporting us. That is why the Agoa renewal passed Congress with overwhelming bipartisan support.
The review itself is done by the administration. So it is an administration decision. Then there is the US Trade Representative, which looks at trade issues, but ultimately it goes to the US president, who would most likely look at political and bilateral relations. That becomes a bit more complicated.
Q: If South Africa is removed, can it get back in before the change takes effect?
Parks: If you are removed, that only takes effect in January. So you have 60 days. Is there space to prevent that? Hopefully.
But there are other things we still need to do. We still need to diversify our trade relations. We need to do that because of our own domestic crisis of 43% unemployment and weak economic growth.
They have done some of that, especially in agriculture, which is the most vulnerable sector. You have seen some movement towards Asia.
But it must be done in a way that does not create other issues, because the problem with China and India is the strings attached.
They want you to open up your market as well, and we are not really in a space to compete equally with them.
Q: How much negotiating power does South Africa have with the US?
Parks: Not much. It is a different style – largely a take-it-or-leave-it approach. And of course it is clouded by bilateral issues that are not related to trade. The US must negotiate from a tough basis because it is looking after its own constituencies, just as SA must do likewise.
Q: Are we giving in too much to the US with concessions?
Parks: I do not think so. The goal of negotiation is about giving something, but it has not even reached that stage yet. This is an unusual time, so the old textbooks do not really apply in the same way.
Q: Should South Africa sacrifice constitutional imperatives, especially on transformation and land rights to appease the US?
Parks: We cannot outsource sovereign choices to another country. That would be political suicide.
That does not mean we do not tweak legislation, policies or regulations, but it must be guided by our domestic economic constraints. If growth is sluggish and unemployment is too high – which they are – then we should look at whether we need to make amendments to our own policies and legislation. That must be guided by South African conditions.
For example, on the B-BBEE review that the government is already busy with, we have said: why not extend equity equivalents for investors who cannot do the 30% shareholding because of their own domestic legislation?
Why not extend employee share-ownership programmes, which many countries prefer, as opposed to the 30% option?
You can find ways to complement the transformation journey while also making it easier for investors to come in. That includes reducing red tape.
One of the biggest things we have seen from investors is not so much on the issue of compliance, but that it takes them about 14 months to get through all the bureaucracy.
We should really be discussing how to reduce that to 14 days, for example, not 14 months.
But that must not mean tinkering with labour standards and labour rights. Luckily, that has not really come up in this round of discussion. We cannot compromise on labour rights, but that does not mean we do not make changes. Changes must be guided by our real economic challenges.